Falcon Theater kicks off its season with a bang!
A play by Jonathan Spector, Eureka Day is the story of a private elementary school that operates by consensus and values all viewpoints. When the school is hit with an outbreak of the mumps, its entire system is thrown into chaos, causing massive debates and upheaval.
In other words, what you might expect from a school board meeting.
The script is hilarious and thought-provoking, and for those of us who were involved in education during the COVID-19 pandemic, it is all too familiar.
A word of warning: The conflict centers around the school’s vaccine policy. While both sides of the argument are presented, the play thoroughly mocks both sides. The online livestream scene in particular devolves almost exactly as you would expect. It’s very funny, but it might not be everyone’s cup of tea.
Solid Ensemble
All in all, everyone on stage does an admirable job of portraying a very concerned and then wildly infuriated school board.
David Derringer, as Eli, at first is a bit rakish, albeit clearly caring and politically correct, individual. His son is in the hospital with mumps after a play date with the daughter of his fellow board member. His need for serious medical care pushes the main plot and adds tension to Eli’s marriage and his relationship with Meiko (the incomparable Julie Locker).
Locker’s portrayal of Meiko is both warm and funny. She plays off Eli incredibly well. They are in a secretive romantic relationship which is falling apart because of circumstances outside their control.
Bekka Eaton, as Suzanne, is hilarious. While I wouldn’t call anyone the villain of this piece, she is the one who slows down the committee due to her own tragic life experience. She plays the role well. She reminds me of conversations I have had with my own aunt: a sweet, lovely human who holds some views that I vehemently disagree with. That dichotomy is an interesting, and at times frustrating, thing to experience.
Kyndra Jefferies, as Catrina, is a fantastic stand-in for the audience. She shows that even a new member of this board can shake things up by taking a realistic, family-based approach to her views. Watching Catrina and Suzanne play off each other is another great source of dramatic tension. I have to say, the subtle facial expressions and shifts really bring the character to life.
Finally, I would be remiss not to mention Rick Grant as Don. The nervous energy and utter joy that Grant brings to the role are infectious. He has some of the funniest moments, and watching him try to contain—and ultimately succumb to—the chaos is hilarious.
Production
Ed Cohen’s direction shows a clear vision, and the additions he makes to the script—particularly the Sound of Music parody bit at the end—are a nice finishing touch.
Corine Felt on costumes and Faith Von Handorf on props really make Falcon’s intimate space feel like an elementary school library.
And Hades Whalen gives a strong showing as assistant director.
Speaking as her former classmate, Katie Ruwe coninues to amaze me as a stage manager. She has a watchful eye and gift for organization. She ensures that even if a show is chaotic, it is organized chaos. Hers is the method to the madness.
Conclusion
Go see Eureka Day! Both and hilarious to though provoking, it is worth your time. The performances are all incredibly strong. While some scenes feature arguments with people talking over each other, there is always something hilarious to see.
Falcon Theatre is one of my favorite spots in the greater Cincinnati area, and it’s due to a constant stream of regional premieres, a wide array of shows, and, dare I say, some of the most comfortable seating you will find in this area’s theater scene.
I have been a fan of Falcon for years, and I cannot wait to see the rest of their season this year.
Remaining Performances: September 17, 18, 19, 24, 25 and 26, 2026
NEW TIME: All performances at 7:30 p.m.
Ticket Link: Falcon Theatre
