Equal parts murder mystery, musical, and comedy, Murder for Two is a whirlwind of laughs, lightning-fast character changes, and nonstop theatrical energy. Running July 22 through 26, 2026, at The Carnegie, this production stars Curtis Reynolds as every suspect and Mark Schenfisch as Officer Marcus Moscowicz. With a runtime of 90 minutes and no intermission, the fast-paced production keeps audiences engaged from beginning to end with clever comedy, memorable characters, and impressive performances.
Two Actors, Many Characters
Curtis Reynolds is a remarkable tour-de-force as all of the suspects. His ability to shift between characters is seamless, with each personality emerging through distinctive voices, movements, and mannerisms. Reynolds’ physical comedy is a highlight throughout the production, and his portrayal of Stephanie is especially impressive. He perfectly captures Gen Z expressions and rhythms while creating a character that is both recognizable and hilarious.
Mark Schenfisch brings an earnest charm and quirky energy to Officer Marcus Moscowicz. His determination to solve the case gives the character a strong sense of purpose. His beautiful singing voice adds warmth to the production. Schenfisch works seamlessly with Reynolds, creating a natural rhythm between Marcus’ investigation and the whirlwind of characters surrounding him. Together, they handle the show’s rapid pace and demanding mix of comedy, music, and timing with remarkable ease.
Why It Works
Murder for Two effortlessly blends multiple styles into one entertaining package. The show embraces the traditions of a classic whodunit while adding musical comedy, physical humor, and audience interaction. The result is a production that feels playful, fresh, and full of surprises.
Whether you come for the comedy, the music, or the challenge of solving the case alongside Officer Moscowicz, there is plenty to enjoy.
Whodunit?
Director Joe Deer keeps the pace sharp and the comedy flowing, while Steve Goers’ musical direction brings energy to the musical numbers. Doug Stock’s lighting design is a standout, using creative shadow play that adds atmosphere, visual interest, and another layer of storytelling to the production. Tyler Gabbard’s scenic design, Cat Schmeal Swope’s costumes, Dani Lobello’s sound design, and the stage management of Carissa Gandenberger help create a polished production that allows Reynolds and Schenfisch to shine.
As Producing Artistic Director, Tyler Gabbard continues to bring engaging and inventive theatre to The Carnegie stage.
Case Closed
Murder for Two is funny, clever, and delightfully bananas, making it a perfect choice for audiences looking for a lively night at the theatre. Curtis Reynolds and Mark Schenfisch deliver exceptional performances, proving just how much energy and entertainment can come from a two-person production.
Murder for Two runs July 22 through 26, 2026, at The Carnegie. The performance runs approximately 90 minutes with no intermission. Tickets are available at thecarnegie.com or by calling (859) 491-2030. Don’t miss this fast-paced musical mystery that proves sometimes the smallest casts can create the biggest laughs.
