By Liz Eichler
Dayton’s Magnolia Theatre is presenting What the Constitution Means to Me through October 20 at the PNC Arts Annex. Written by Heidi Schreck, the show has enjoyed a successful run on Broadway and in regional theaters since 2019. It explores the impact of the Constitution on personal lives, particularly through the eyes of a 15-year-old Heidi who competes in the American Legion Constitution Contest. The highlight of the show is in the second act, when the debate begins…and the audience hears both sides of compelling arguments to keep or abolish the Constitution.
The Story of “Consitution“
The first act dives into Heidi’s background, revealing her family’s struggles and triumphs.
The premise is a 15-year old Heidi earns enough money on the American Legion speaking circuit that she can pay her way through college. She dives into the articles of the constitution, especially the Ninth Amendment—which Schreck refers to as the “penumbra” of the Constitution. We hear the stories of her mother, grandmother and great great grandmother, and see how their protections were in the shadowy areas of the law. Or the interpretations of it.
Performances and Production
Gina Handy plays Heidi, who is a master of smiles–and conjures up the perfect awkward yet confident 15-year old. We see Heidi as a teen, Heidi as an adult, Gina as Heidi, and Gina as Gina. We also meet the Legionnaire/Danny (Robb Willoughby) and a Debater (Meg Adams on the night I saw the show). Directed by Michelle Hayford, it is written as an education as well as a deeply personal journey. There are trigger warnings: the show deals with rape, abuse, abortion and more.
Handy’s delivery ensures that these moments resonate, but the pacing occasionally feels drawn out. The highlight comes in the second act, where the debate unfolds. Danny first shares his story about growing up gay in the midwest dominated by toxic male attitudes. When the Debater enters, Adam’s crisp and commanding but warm delivery is welcome. Both sides debate amendments and both are capable in making compelling arguments. This segment is timely given the political climate and calendar, allowing the audience to engage with differing viewpoints—a rare treat. One audience member will choose to keep or abolish the Constitution each night. (On our night she chose to keep it.)
The founding fathers are present through their many many portraits arranged on the back wall. (How many can you identify?) The lighting (Erin McLaughlin) adapts to support every nuance.

Tickets to What the Constitution Means to Me
Overall, What the Constitution Means to Me It is a powerful tapestry of personal stories and larger societal issues. This show pours them into a cauldron, and gets us steaming. The inclusion of pocket copies of the Constitution is a nice touch, encouraging further contemplation long after the curtain falls. The show runs only through October 20 at the PNC Annex in Dayton. For tickets and more information click here.