This February, Know Theatre of Cincinnati presents the regional premiere of Constellations by Nick Payne. Described in short as “One relationship. Infinite possibilities.” It tells the story (or stories) through multiverse theory of a couple who meet at a barbecue, date, and break up…or live happily ever after…or maybe none of the above.
The Production Team
Producing Artistic Director Bridget Leak takes the helm on this journey through the proverbial stars. Per usual, she provides a series of stunning stage pictures–which in a play like this one (no spoilers!) is even more important than usual. Ms. Leak’s rock-solid instincts continue to serve her well as she manages impeccable pacing and purposeful movement for two actors who never leave the stage. Complementing the action on stage without distracting is an ethereal set designed by Melissa Bennett and brought to life by Scenic Artisan Samantha Reno. The set is both grand and minimal at the same time which is a feat within itself. Lighting Design by Marly Wooster (assisted by Ben Trader) is absolutely everything: it is subtle, deliberate, and sets the scenes perfectly.
The Performing Artists
Finding two actors to portray two people with so many stories to tell seems a tall order–but not with these actors. Both artists are fundamentally likable, yet unafraid to show us the not-so-likable parts of humans in their portrayals.
Caitlin McWethy (in her Know Theatre debut–I couldn’t believe it, either!) is effervescent as Marianne, a quantum physicist whose personal journey plays out before us. It should come as no surprise a seasoned veteran like Ms. McWethy offers a performance we shall never forget. Her Marianne is incredibly affable with seemingly no effort whatsoever. Her endearing smile and infectious energy fill up not only the entire stage, but the entire building.
Never one to back down from a challenge, Phineas Clark matches every volley thrown by his co-star exceptionally. As thriving beekeeper Roland, Mr. Clark is everything you expect him to be. He too gives a tour-de-force performance with an ease that will make you forget you are watching a play. His Roland is gruff, but vulnerable; dominant, yet sensitive –and everything else in between. Mr. Clark is indeed a very generous actor and, when matched with an equally generous scene partner like Ms. McWethy, your investment in their future(s) will be a certainty.
The Sweet and Lowdown
Since I see and do quite a bit of theatre, it is not often I am “surprised” by a script; however, Constellations is one of those exceptions. There is something both intriguing and somewhat frightening about the idea of a multiverse: that our lives are paved by what we do and do not choose. Even if we live in a singular verse, this has some logic to it. Are we pre-destined or do we truly have control over our own choices? So many possibilities and so many questions; yet, relationships are always at the heart of it. I know some humans whom I’d want to be present in all my multiverses; can we all say the same?
Get Tickets to Constellations
Constellations presented by Know Theatre of Cincinnati runs now through February 22nd, 2026. With so many options like Industry Monday ticket deals, Understudy Performances, and Welcome Thursday, you can find the right fit for your schedule and budget. For more information about the production and to purchase tickets for this limited run, please visit here.
—
LCT reviews are edited by Liz Eichler, Stage Insights Chair and Member of American Theatre Critics Association
