This week, Cincinnati Landmark Productions opened 1776 at the Warsaw Federal Incline Theater. This production is perfectly timed between Memorial Day and the Fourth of July to fulfill everyone’s patriotic needs.
The Story
There could hardly be a more fitting time to revisit 1776 than during the nation’s 250th anniversary, and Cincinnati Landmark Productions has seized the moment with a vibrant, thoughtful, and highly entertaining production of the beloved musical. While the 250th anniversary of American independence provides an especially meaningful backdrop for this staging, this is not the first time CLP has tackled 1776. In fact, several performers are returning to the revolutionary event in entirely different roles. These moments take CLP’s production over-the-top by creating a fascinating connection between past productions and this landmark celebration.
Set in Independence Hall during the summer of 1776, the story follows John Adams (Josh Stothfang) as he pushes the reluctant Second Continental Congress to vote for independence from Great Britain. Adams must persuade fellow delegates to overcome regional rivalries, personal disagreements, and concerns about slavery. With a committee of five: Thomas Jefferson (Tyler Owen Parsons), Benjamin Franklin (John Dorney), Roger Sherman (Griffin Hatfield) and Robert Livingston (Jake Schaub), and Adams (Stothfang) himself, the delegates struggle between their commitment to honor and everyday life. The musical combines humor with historical drama that leads to the delegates’ decision to approve the Declaration and formally establish the United States as an independent nation.
Performances
At the center of the action is Josh Stothfang as John Adams. Stothfang captures Adams’ relentless determination and fiery temper making him a compelling anchor for the evening. The emotional core of the show is strengthened considerably by Delaney O’Toole as Abigail Adams. Her rich vocals and genuine connection with Stothfang elevate “Yours, Yours, Yours” into a highlight of the evening. O’Toole captures Abigail’s intelligence, resilience, and affection, reminding audiences of the vital role women played despite being absent from the halls of Congress.
John Dorney brings warmth and humor to Benjamin Franklin. Dorney’s goofy charisma makes Franklin an ideal mediator among the increasingly frustrated delegates. His comic timing provides many of the production’s biggest laughs. Together, Stothfang and Dorney establish a strong partnership that helps drive the plot. This partnership is soon turned into a trio with the addition of Tyler Owen Parsons as Thomas Jefferson. Parsons gives Thomas Jefferson an appealing mix of intellect and hesitation. His appeal is matched by Franny Bell’s Martha Jefferson. Bell shines during the beautiful “He Plays the Violin,” one of the production’s most vocally remarkable moments. Bell brings grace and warmth to the role, creating a memorable appearance despite limited stage time.
Ryan J. Poole is excellent as John Dickinson, serving as a formidable opponent to Adams. Poole presents Dickinson as a principled man whose caution stems from genuine conviction. The debates between Adams and Dickinson become some of the evening’s most engaging scenes because both performers ground their characters in authenticity.
Christopher Wells delivers one of the production’s standout performances as Edward Rutledge. His powerful rendition of “Molasses to Rum” is the appropriate mix of chilling and showtunes, forcing both the delegates and the audience to confront the hypocrisy embedded within the founding of the nation. Wells handles the difficult material with confidence and skill, creating one of the show’s most impactful sequences.
Other notable performances are by Joseph O’Hair, Tyler Gau and Patrick Vaughn. O’Hair is thoroughly entertaining as Richard Henry Lee, making the most of every appearance. His spirited performance of “The Lees of Old Virginia” brings a welcome burst of energy and humor. Gau provides a steady and likable presence as Charles Thomson, bringing one of the most genuine characters to the stage. Vaughn brings sincerity and heart to Dr. Lyman Hall as the often-overlooked delegate struggles with questions of loyalty and representation.
Design and Direction
Under the direction of Tim Perrino, 1776 balances historical accuracy with the wit, humor, and spectacle that have made the musical a favorite over the years. Perrino and his team have a production that feels both timely and timeless, reminding audiences that history can be entertaining.
If you’re an historical drama lover, then this show is for you. June Hill and the CLP Costume Team deserve praise for their beautiful costume design. The period attire combines authenticity and elegance with color and texture making it a joy for the eye to behold. Equally impressive are the numerous period-specific wigs designed by Jenny Herndon. The wigs add another layer of historical detail and craftsmanship that significantly enhances the production overall.
Brett Bowling’s scenic design is both interesting and highly functional. The set effectively evokes the Continental Congress while providing the flexibility necessary to keep the action flowing smoothly. Bowling’s design allows the actors to play with the space without becoming cumbersome, allowing the performers to remain the focus.
Overall
As America marks its 250th anniversary, Cincinnati Landmark Productions’ 1776 feels particularly meaningful. The combination of returning artists stepping into new roles, a talented cast, and a skilled creative team makes this more than a simple revival. Thoughtful, engaging, funny, and moving, this production demonstrates why 1776 continues to speak to audiences 250 years later.
Tickets to 1776 at Incline
1776 at the Incline Theatre runs through June 21, 2026, at 801 Matson Pl, Cincinnati, OH 45204. Purchase tickets at the box office, online HERE, or by calling 513-241-6550.
